A minister's wife drowns in her own bathtub. Her husband says it was an accident. Months later, at trial, a suicide note surfaces from nowhere — and a forensic look inside two computers tells a very different story about who actually wrote it.
1999
Emergency crews restarted her heart and placed her on a respirator, but she never regained consciousness. Doctors found no signs of brain activity, and she was pronounced dead the next day.
The medical examiner listed the cause of death as drowning, with the temazepam overdose a contributing factor, but left the manner of death undetermined — accident, suicide, or homicide were all still on the table.
“The most important drug was temazepam... present in very high concentrations.”— Dr. Brad Randall, medical examiner
Investigators also found that weeks before her death, Bill had filled his temazepam prescription at one pharmacy, then told a second pharmacy he'd lost it and got a second supply — and that his clothes were dry despite his claim of trying to physically pull Sharon from the tub.
The affair had reportedly ended that January when his mistress grew tired of its secrecy, pressured him for more, and ultimately broke things off.
He denied everything — the affair, obtaining the extra medication, all of it — leaving investigators with suspicion but no direct admission.
Robbins explained that deleting a file doesn't erase it — it just marks that space as available, often leaving recoverable traces behind if nothing has overwritten it yet.
He also found searches about bathtub accidents, a detail that struck him as odd until he learned how Sharon had actually died. On April 29th, Bill requested the temazepam prescription he filled at two pharmacies; it was refilled again on May 12th and 13th, the day before she died.
Their theory held that once the drug took effect, he placed her unconscious body in the tub, filled it with water, and let her drown — then returned home to find her and call for help.
“I felt we had a pretty good circumstantial case, but all our evidence was circumstantial.”— Mike Moore, prosecutor
The family was already split on what they believed had happened, well before the trial produced its most dramatic twist.
The note apologized for "ruining" an earlier wedding and referenced a minor incident from years before — details that gave it an air of authenticity the prosecution hadn't anticipated.
“I won't be there, so put your mind at ease. You will understand after the wedding is done.”— The suicide note attributed to Sharon Guthrie
The prints found didn't match Bill or his attorney, who he said he'd given the note to directly. Since Sharon had never been fingerprinted, even at autopsy, there was no way yet to compare the prints to her.
“Somebody was perspiring quite heavily while they were handling that document.”— Cynthia Orton, fingerprint expert
The file had been created in August, three months after Sharon's death — and Robbins found it interspersed in the computer's file history with several of Bill's sermons from that same month, letting him reconstruct a timeline of Bill writing sermons and the "suicide note" in alternating sessions.
“I think at that point, it made me realize... that he was guilty for this.”— Judd Robbins, computer forensics expert
Prosecutor Mike Moore said the forensic evidence — the toxicology, the computer searches, and the reconstructed note — was the entire case; without it, he said, there would have been no way to charge Guthrie at all.
early 2000s
Whose fingerprints are actually on the note has never been explained. The case's forensic conclusion — that Bill wrote and planted it — stood regardless, but that one specific detail was left unresolved.
“The question that leaves me with is whose fingerprints are on that document?”— Cynthia Orton, fingerprint expert
One daughter summed up the year of the investigation and trial as costing her, in different ways, both of her parents and her sister.
No events match the current filters. Try resetting.