A semen sample was preserved from the scene for future DNA testing — technology that didn't yet exist in a form that could identify her killer, but that investigators had the foresight to save anyway.
Four weeks later, her body was found in a field off US Route 281. An old bus 100 feet away held blood matching Toni — it appeared she'd been stabbed inside it, then crawled out into the field looking for help.
Investigators also learned Laughlin had mentioned knowing where the field was located — circumstantial details that, combined, made him the prime suspect despite the lack of hard forensic evidence.
Despite the lack of forensic confirmation, prosecutors charged Laughlin with the murder anyway, built largely on the circumstantial details investigators already had.
Prosecutors chose not to retry the case. Laughlin walked away formally unconvicted, but with the accusation still hanging over him.
The killer drove her car back into town and abandoned it. Ellen's body wasn't found for days, and by then was too decomposed to confirm whether she'd been sexually assaulted — she could only be identified through dental records.
Danny Laughlin didn't match the witness description and wasn't considered a suspect in this case — this murder would turn out to belong to someone else entirely.
Wardrip admitted to killing her, saying she reminded him of his ex-wife, who had recently ended their marriage. Police believe he confessed because he knew he'd been seen leaving her apartment.
In prison, Wardrip got his GED and said he found religion, later describing it as the point he decided to "come out better" than he went in.
Neighbors described him as trustworthy and upstanding — a reputation that existed entirely unaware of what investigators were about to uncover.
They matched — proving a single perpetrator was behind both murders. No one had made that connection before, because the cases had been investigated by three separate agencies that rarely communicated.
Little also discovered Wardrip had worked as a janitor at the same hospital as Toni Gibbs, and lived near where her car was abandoned — a web of coincidences that, once laid out together, pointed unmistakably in one direction.
Among several discarded cups, Little identified the right one by the coffee left inside and cheese cracker crumbs on the rim — he'd watched Wardrip eating the same crackers minutes earlier.
The combination of genetic markers in Wardrip's profile was so uncommon it would be expected to occur only once in the entire world's population — about as close to certainty as DNA evidence gets.
Investigators believe the print was left when Wardrip pulled the shoes from Sims' feet with blood still on his hands.
Wardrip said Taylor's husband had briefly left the bar before them; when Taylor refused his advances in the parking lot, he killed her and dumped her body at a construction site. Her husband, Ken, had been informally suspected for 14 years and never charged — his life upended by suspicion for a murder he didn't commit.
Laughlin never learned he'd been cleared — he had died in a car accident three years before the exoneration came through.
He later said he never believed he'd gotten away with it — he knew he'd left evidence behind, and was puzzled that his name, which had surfaced in the files as early as 1986, wasn't connected sooner.