Maynard, a doctor himself, reassured her it was nothing serious and had her lie down. The symptoms passed by the next day, and neither Michelle nor her own physician suspected anything at the time.
Michelle was troubled that he'd previously described Tammy so negatively, yet still seemed attached to her — an early crack in a relationship that looked, from the outside, like a whirlwind romance.
She had a neighbor drive her to Tammy Irwin's house and found Maynard there. He admitted Tammy hadn't even known he was living with Michelle. Michelle threw him out.
An ultrasound afterward showed the fetus was fine, and doctors again chalked it up to stress. The pattern was becoming harder to explain away, even if no one had named it yet.
Michelle then recalled that Maynard had personally brought her drinks both in Key West and at the picnic, right before each episode began.
That single overheard line was the moment Michelle went from suspicious to genuinely afraid for her pregnancy, and she went straight to the police.
Without physical evidence, there was little police could act on. They told Michelle they'd need proof tying Maynard directly to whatever was happening.
She swapped the drink for a fresh one, saved the original in a hidden container, and sat through dinner as if nothing had happened. That same night, Maynard told her Tammy was upset because he'd secretly married her that week.
Gas chromatography–mass spectrometry testing confirmed a match between the substance in Michelle's drink and known cytotec, giving investigators their first concrete answer.
Detectives Colvin and May watched from the garage as Maynard, almost identically to before, slipped a vial into Michelle's drink the moment she stepped outside. They moved in and arrested him on the spot.
When asked directly whether "the problem" he'd referred to was the baby, he confirmed it was — an admission that, combined with two independently confirmed poisoned samples, left little room for an innocent explanation.
His own physician colleague, who had reassured Michelle during her pregnancy, later said he was ashamed to share a profession with him.
Michelle's family gathered to hold the baby and say goodbye. The transcript is explicit that the coroner did not establish a direct medical link between the poisoning and the stillbirth — a distinction worth keeping clear rather than assuming causation.
Muntzing was sentenced to 5 years in prison and lost his medical license. Tammy received probation. Michelle Baker continued her work as a firefighter and paramedic, hoping her story would help others.