Phil's friend Kimo Coelho also joined the company. By all appearances, things were going well for everyone involved.
He lost 30 pounds and began struggling cognitively — at one point telling his wife he thought he had Alzheimer's after forgetting the route to his own shop.
Phil later said nothing could have convinced him otherwise that night — doctors, meanwhile, were doubtful his illness was workplace-related, since no one else at the shop had gotten sick.
Reviewing the checks, Phil found Steve had been paying his own cell phone bill, personal insurance, and liquor purchases out of company funds.
There was no reciprocal policy naming Phil as beneficiary on Steve's life. Steve's wife later said the policy was only meant to protect their investment in case Phil died.
Phil said he'd signed a number of documents Steve brought over without fully understanding them, trusting a friend he'd known for years.
Merigian explained that arsenic doesn't stay traceable in the body long — it's excreted or sequestered in bone — meaning this single test could confirm exposure but not pin down when or how much.
The combination — recurring illness tied to specific meals, and a business partner with real chemistry expertise — reframed everything Phil had been experiencing.
The results showed no poison exposure during a hospital stay, but clear traces of mercury during the periods Phil had been living and working at home — pinpointing not just that he'd been poisoned, but roughly when.
A jar labeled "baking powder" tested positive for mercury and an odorless, tasteless formulation of arsenic. Steve's wife said the setup was meant to interest their children in science.
Confronted with the lab results, Steve called the accusation absurd and offered to drink whatever they'd found — while separately arguing that if he'd wanted to kill Phil, he'd have used something faster-acting than arsenic.
Phil and his friend Kimo recalled several specific incidents: Steve swapping entrées at a restaurant, insisting Phil finish a full bottle of wine, leaving Phil alone with coffee during visits, and both men falling ill after Steve brought them hamburgers.
Prosecutors argued that possessing the poisons at all was the relevant fact, regardless of whether any single dose would have been lethal on its own.
Witnesses, including several waitresses, described White as an unusually generous tipper — once leaving a $60 tip on a $15 check — painting a picture of someone spending well beyond a teacher's income.
Phil's wife credited the heavy metals testing and Dr. Merigian's work directly with saving his life. Phil's car restoration business ultimately closed, and he was left with permanent numbness and mobility problems from the nerve damage.