Investigators noted the extended nature of the assault — repeated blows to the head and upper chest, not a single strike — and the total absence of witnesses or a matching missing-persons report.
The conditions had to be exact: no emergency personnel could have touched the body, the victim couldn't have been dead too long, and the temperature had to be neither too hot nor too cold for prints to survive at all.
On Martha's left thigh, the fumes revealed a fragment of a palm print, left by someone steadying themselves there during the attack. It was only the second time a latent print had ever been confirmed on human skin.
Combined with the palm print, investigators now had two separate physical leads pointing toward whoever had attacked her.
Investigators noted the extent of contact with the body suggested the attacker had spent real time with Martha, both before and after her death.
Investigators were now looking for a specific kind of person: a Native Alaskan man with waist-length black hair carrying an irregular orange tint from incomplete bleaching.
The footage came from a bar called the Avenue, which ran nine cameras covering nearly every inch of the premises.
Martha had been missing two days before her children reported it, which was why police hadn't yet connected her to their unidentified victim.
She'd initially dismissed it as drunken bragging. The friend was Evans Lee Curtis, whose hair fell almost to his waist and who matched the surveillance image closely.
Interrogated, Curtis denied any involvement in Martha's murder and argued he wasn't the only long-haired man in Anchorage.
It was an unusual enough pattern that the match was considered strong corroborating evidence on its own, even before the print and DNA results came back.
The match left Curtis with a direct problem to explain: how his palm print ended up on a murdered woman's body.
The boot-heel detail corresponded to what looked like a heel impression on Martha's body, suggesting Curtis had stepped on her during the attack.
Prosecutors believed the two recognized each other by chance after Martha left the bar, and that what began as a friendly walk turned violent when Curtis made a sexual advance she rejected.
Investigators described the case as a rare convergence of old-fashioned detective work, an experimental forensic technique, and luck — crediting the superglue-fuming print as evidence unlike anything used in an Alaska case before.